7 users logged onTips: BlueJerseyDotCom (AIM) |      
Log In
Sign Up | Forgot Password?

Why we need to support a Responsible Plan for Iraq (Updated)

by: Juan Melli

Mon Mar 17, 2008 at 06:34:06 PM EDT



Update: 11th district Congressional candidate Tom Wyka has also endorsed the plan. You can leave a nice thank you note at his Act Blue page.

It's incredibly difficult to run a Congressonal campaign as a non-incumbent challenger. The lucky ones get support from organizations like the DCCC and EMILY's list. They might provide staff, research, polling, advice and if they're fortunate...money. And because these groups want their candidates to win, they put subtle and sometimes not-so-subtle demands on those candidates to steer them in a direction they think is best to ensure victory. Candidates face enormous pressure to fundraise, fundraise and fundraise more. Substantive long-term planning and meaningful organizing on the part of the candidates is not a top priority.

That's part of what makes today's announcement of Washington state congressional candidate (WA-8) Darcy Burner's "Responsible Plan" (pdf) to end the war in Iraq so inspiring. For too long the debate on Iraq has focused almost exclusively on military matters. This comprehensive plan was developed in consultation with military experts like two-time George W Bush voter Major General Paul Eaton and former assistant secretary of defense in the Reagan administration Dr. Lawrence Korb.

Darcy announced her plan today at the Take Back America Conference in Washington DC. She and 9 other Congressional challenges are the nucleus of a caucus of challengers with the courage to bring about change on Iraq.

Besides calling for removing all troops from Iraq (no residual troops), the plan addresses the humanitarian crisis that is destabilizing the entire region and calls for diplomacy with Iraq's neighbors - some of whom are contributing to that instability. It's forward-looking and recognizes the need to "repair the underlying Constitutional framework of our republic and provide checks to executive authority" by restoring habeus corpus, eliminating Presidential signing statements, and clarifying that the government still has to respect the Fourth Amendment and can't spy on its own people without probable cause. Finally it calls for repairing our military by phasing out the use of mercenaries, "restoring benefits for members of the military and veterans, and investment in repairing or replacing damaged military equipment," and protecting our military members by clearly stating that our country will not engage in - or outsource - torture.

This is not a press release that was cranked out in a few hours. It's a real plan that has been thoughtfully considered and developed over a period of months in consultation with respected military experts. It's the type of thing that eats into valuable fundraising time, which is why candidates are so strongly discouraged from doing it. Further, I can't speak for Darcy Burner specifically, but EMILY's list has a history of knee-capping female candidates on the issue of Iraq and military policy in general by insisting that they "talk tough." This counterproductive strategy sometimes leads candidates to end up fighting from weak defensive positions.

Darcy has sacrificed valuable fundraising time and probably overcome significant pressure to create this plan. She and the other 9 candidates who are endorsing the effort deserve our support to show that we value thoughtful, meaningful and substantive leadership. They are trying to build a caucus of challengers who will sweep into Congress with a mandate to change the course in Iraq.

To my knowledge, only one candidate from New Jersey has endorsed the plan so far - rabbi Dennis Shulman (support Shulman on ActBlue). "We were delighted to be offered a chance to join these powerful voices in articulating the need for change," said Shulman "and we are signing onto the plan formally later this week." (Update: Tom Wyka has also endorsed the plan. See his comment for details and then visit his Act Blue page.)

When January 2009 comes around, the next Congress will face the daunting task of fixing eight years of catastrophic blunders. This caucus of candidates who campaign and are elected on this platform will have a mandate from the people who elect them.

It's important that all of our Congressional challengers join this caucus. Please contact them and let them know how important this is. And don't forget to support those candidates who showed courage and are already on board. You can also go to ResponsiblePlan.com to learn more and sign up to endorse the plan yourself.

  • Mahdi Ibn-Ziyad (NJ-1) Ibnziyadd@aol.com
  • John Adler (NJ-3) info@adlerforcongress.com, 856-222-9707
  • Camille Abate (NJ-5) contact, 201-857-5050
  • Linda Stender (NJ-7) contact@lindastenderforcongress.com
  • Tom Wyka (NJ-11) wykaforcongress@yahoo.com
  • Juan Melli :: Why we need to support a Responsible Plan for Iraq (Updated)
    Tags: , , , (All Tags)
    Print Friendly View Send As Email
    Endorsement (with some comments...) (0.00 / 0)
    Just a few...

    The elements of the "Restoring the Constitution" section is certainly a priority - but that's a responsible plan for America overall, not just regarding issues concerning our involvement Iraq.  I think Habeas Corpus, signing statements, and Foreign Surveillance are issues to address outside this document.    Media consolidation, War-Profiteering, Mercenaries, Benefits for Veterans, are certainly relevant within this plan.  From my own perspective - many of my supporters know that my overall concern over the issue of money in our political process cannot be ignored when it comes to defense contracting and the media.  It's a central mission of my campaign to shine a light on this distortion in our democracy, which I think is long overdue.

    Not sure if I missed it in the plan - but I also would like to see an effort toward the federation idea for the three regions, as proposed by Sen. Biden previously.

    Overall - I believe all other elements of this plan are indeed reasonable and responsible and I would endorse this plan overall.


    Endorsement? (0.00 / 0)
    I commend you, Mr. Wyka, for being among the first New Jersey candidates to comment in support of this plan.  However, I have some concern about your comment that you "would endorse this plan overall."  Judging by what you said earlier - that "Habeas Corpus, signing statements, and Foreign Surveillance are issues to address outside this document" - I am not sure you truly endorse this plan.

    To be certain, I do NOT fault you for not endorsing this plan, if that is the case.  If you have concerns about the specifics, that is your right.  It is refreshing to see a candidate not fall in to the trap of discussing gray areas in terms of black and white, yes and no.  It tells me that, in the House, you will be a thoughtful voice of reason, not just one of the herd.

    I would just offer some caution to say what you mean and mean what you say... as fits your reputation.  "Endorsing" this plan has a very specific meaning to those putting it forward and I would not want to see you criticized for endorsing the plan and then backing away from certain parts later, even if you had expressed concern about them from the beginning.


    [ Parent ]
    This was Richardson's plan (0.00 / 0)
    This is basically Richardson's campaign platform.  I wish the DFA and MoveOn had supported him.  

    The 1st plane load can come home tonight (0.00 / 0)
    just sayin....

    Check out my 3 paragraph primer on Polywell Fusion.

    ADVERTISEMENT
    Featured Stories
    Time for my next step
    by: Jason Springer - Jul 27
    14 Comments

    Blue Jersey Radio

    The Voice of NJ Politics
    » Next show: Tues. @ 8:00p
    » Hosts: Jeff Gardner & Jason Springer
    » Call in: (646) 652-2773
    » iTunes Subscribe | Archives



    Connect with
    Blue Jersey

    Hate Ads? Make them disappear.
    Subscribe:

    Blue Jersey Essentials

     EDITORIAL DIRECTOR
     Rosi Efthim

     TECHNICAL DIRECTOR
     Jason Springer

     STAFF WRITERS
     Adam L a/k/a/ clammyc
     bytheshore73
     Hopeful
     Jeff Gardner
     Scott Weingart
     Senator Loretta Weinberg
     Vincent Solomeno
     Jason Springer
     Rosi Efthim

    » About | FAQ | In the News
    » 
    » Tips:
    » Front Page RSS Feed
    » User Diaries RSS Feed
    » Blue Jersey on Twitter » Blue Jersey on Facebook » Blue Jersey T-shirts
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Blog Roll

    » Alicia Menendez
    » Alive and Kickin
    » Barista of Bloomfield Ave
    » Blog the Fifth
    » Capitol Quickies
    » The Center of NJ Life
    » Channel Surfing
    » Daily Newarker
    » The Englewood Report
    » Frank Lobiondo Record
    » Fred Snowflack
    » Freedom to Tinker
    » Fresh Jersey (Mike Kelly)
    » Garden State Grapevine
    » Gloucester City News
    » Green Jersey
    » Herb Jackson
    » Hoboken Journal
    » Hoboken Now
    » The Inside Clamdigger
    » Jersey Blogs
    » Jersey Jazz Man
    » Lassiter Space
    » Latinos NJ
    » Middletown Mike
    » More Monmouth Musings
    » NJ Domestic Partnership
    » NJ Politics Unusual
    » NJ Voices: Policy Watch
    » On Our Radar
    » The Opinion Mill
    » Other Spaces
    » Plainfield Plaintalker
    » PolitickerNJ
    » Retire Garrett
    » Ruins of Trenton
    » Senator Ray Lesniak
    » Stovetop Diplomacy
    » Sustainable Cherry Hill
    » The Subversive Garden
    » Teaneck Progress
    » Trenton Kat
    » We Don't Need Permission
    » Xpatriated Texan

    Cartoons

    » M.e. Cohen
    » Jimmy Margulies
    » Drew Sheneman
    » Rob Tornoe
    Search




    Advanced Search











    Ads do not constitute
    an endorsement
    from Blue Jersey.



    Blue Jersey Gear

    Visit the Blue Jersey store. T-shirts, bumper stickers & more!


    Shirts available in dozens of styles and colors.






    Visit the Blue Jersey Store

    Contact Us
    » Editor: 
    » Press releases: 
    » Advertising inquiries: 
    » Tips:
    About Us
    » About Blue Jersey
    » Blue Jersey in the News
    » FAQ/Usage
    » 
    » RSS Feed

    Misc Stuff
    » Blue Jersey Radio
    » Blue Jersey on Twitter
    » Facebook Group
    » MySpace Page
    » NJ Politics 101 Wiki
    » Blue Jersey Podcast
    » Screaming Carrot Award
    » Contribute to Blue Jersey
    6304 satisfied users, visits and 0 subpoenas served since Sept 28, 2005
    © Blue Jersey, powered by the mighty SoapBlox.