4 users logged onTips: BlueJerseyDotCom (AIM) |      

Log In
Sign Up | Forgot Password?

Get Your Ark Ready

by: carolh

Sat Aug 27, 2011 at 09:42:05 AM EDT



Don't let the time-stamp on this put you off reading it. It was written during the hurricane. But we still have towns grappling with water. This is fascinating, and I didn't know any of it. Carolh is a stormwater engineer, and here she walks us through why we flood. Thanks Carol. - promoted by Rosi.

As Hurricane Irene, now a Category 1, bears down on us, as a stormwater drainage engineer, I need to remind folks that rainfall from ANY category hurricane can be deadly.  It isn't just the water from the storm surge - it's the water from the sky.  

carolh :: Get Your Ark Ready
August has already been a very very wet month and reports that just 2" more will tip us over the edge. The ground just can't absorb any more.   A slow moving hurricane makes the rainfall flooding threat that much worse.  And this will be a long event.

As a drainage engineer, I should explain how we design things here in New Jersey. When we design storage devices to hold water before sending it to the municipal drain pipes, we design for the 100 year event that Governor Christie mentioned.  The amount of rainfall in a 100 year event is 8 inches of rainfall.  We design in case it all happens in the space of 10 minutes - a worst case.  HOWEVER, nearly all the drainage pipes found throughout NJ are designed to carry only the 25 year storm capacity.  That is the best case - when the pipes are new and there is no sediment sitting in them and choking off the flow.  Meaning, our infrastructure WILL be overwhelmed by this event if the amount of rainfall exceeds roughly 6.7 inches of rain, which a slow moving hurricane can easily do. NOAA reports we may expect 6 to 10 inches, with isolated rainfall up to 15 inches.  We are guaranteed trouble from Irene.  We have already seen rainfalls greater than this just this year - which has caused widespread flooding in the Pascack Valley and elsewhere.

To make matters worse, the way we improve water quality, in impoundment ponds, is try to maximize the length of time the water sits in the pond so that 24 hours after a storm at least 10% of the stormwater volume is still in the pond.  This actually reduces the storage available should we have an extremely large event of long duration - like in this case.  It is almost certain we will exceed the 100 year event and most detention ponds and underground storage chambers may be easily overtopped.

A few months ago when we experienced devastating floods in Paterson and Wayne, I wrote about the major reasons why we flood. http://www.bluejersey.com/diar... It was technical and a bit boring, but folks may be more willing to read it now.  Our preparation for flooding events shouldn't just happen days before a major hurricane.  It shouldn't be a case of the average citizen after the fact demanding that elected officials just "do something!"  While we did not cause the hurricane (well we maybe did due to human-induced climate change) we are all responsible in our small ways as citizens for increased runoff and the only real solution will take the efforts of everyone working together.  When we pave over our backyards without a thought, when we widen our already humongous driveways, when we put concrete patios absolutely everywhere, when we direct the downspout on our house directly to the driveway that leads to the street, when we connect our sump pump directly to the catch basin, WE are the problem.  Whenever we cut down just one tree, we add to runoff.  When we clear our yards to build a bigger lawn we add to the runoff.  

In the Pascack Valley right now a battle is raging between the residents of the Pascack Valley and the water company.  The residents believe that the flooding where they live (which by the way is in a designated flood plain and has been for years) is all caused by the action or the inaction of the water company, when the real reason for the increase in runoff is the thousands of residential homes and commercial parking lots - many of them new, that each contribute more runoff to the whole system than they ever did - without a second thought.  Every tree that is cut, every forested acre replaced with a McMansion with a tennis court and a palatial entrance with an airplane runway-sized driveway and entrance courtyard, contributes to the problem.

We cannot solve the problem by demanding the water company empty the reservoir before every rainfall. We ALL need to take responsibility.  That includes finding ways of returning the runoff profile to what it was before we built up NJ. It is possible with new techniques called LID or Low Impact Development.  By mimicking Mother Nature, we can reduce the amount of runoff BEFORE it ever gets to the stream or creek or river and it becomes the water company's responsibility.  The NJDEP has already come up with help for designing LID methods:  http://www.nj.gov/dep/stormwat...

LID is less than 20 years old, but the NJDEP has been working with private industry to come up with ways to reduce runoff. The problem is that most elected officials in the state have never heard of these techniques and lack the political will to really encourage their use - because much of the burden of using these new methods lies with the residents and property owners (read - the taxpayers and the voters) in each town.  The answer we are finding is not the huge Hoover dam-like solution that many folks have seen in the past and are calling for because it is all they know, but a team effort by all involved stakeholders - ESPECIALLY home owners.  We cannot dam or pipe our way out of this problem.  The science is pointing to a more DE-centralized approach.  We want to stop the rivulets from each property before they combine into a raging river.  At the same time, we will recharge our groundwater, which is more effective in a decentralized approach.  If we do it right, it's a win-win.

Here is the NJDEP's  excellent webpage that we drainage engineers use to design systems in NJ.  Everything you ever wanted to know about stormwater but were afraid to ask.  http://www.nj.gov/dep/stormwater/

Good luck tonite folks - and stay safe.  This is going to be tough, as we lose trees they may make stream flooding even worse as they block watercourses.  Get to high ground, safe indoors, and think about what I've said here as you wait it out by candlelight....

Tags: , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Get Your Ark Ready | 16 comments
Sadly, not a single comment. (0.00 / 0)
From anyone.  Does anybody ever read stuff BEFORE catastrophes happen anymore?  Or do we just like the shouting and fingerpointing later? Or the cheap political shots at the Governor when he trying to do the best he can at a moment of crisis when we need to pull together?  A stormwater engineer gives advice here on how to prevent flooding in NJ, and NOBODY ABSOLUTELY NOBODY gives a damn before the flood happens.  Sometimes I wonder why  I even bother...

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.

I think we were mainly... (0.00 / 0)
Offline on Saturday preparing. It's a very good analysis of the problem that bears reading even after the storm - thanks for posting it.

[ Parent ]
Thanks for reading it. (0.00 / 0)
The other diary this one references called "Why We Flood" http://www.bluejersey.com/diar...  has been up since March.  Unfortunately there is not one single comment on that one either.  

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.

[ Parent ]
Thanks for frontpaging this, Rosie :) (4.00 / 1)
I think folks now understand what I was getting at. I do need to give a shout out to one Blue Jersey veteran who pointed out the dire situation Paterson faces all the time from the terrible threat they faced this week.  Jeff Gardner was trying to call attention to flooding in Paterson months ago.  http://www.politickernj.com/46...  

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.

please re-tweet and post on your FB walls. n/t (0.00 / 0)
A Desert Solution That Worked For Irene (0.00 / 0)
Coming from California where people spend as much on water in a month as the Real Housewives of J spend on shoes in a week, we know a thing or two about maximizing the use of runoff in order to reduce the need for outdoor watering. I'll leave the big municipal projects up to the experts, but there are things that I have done that have reduced the runoff from my property that help the greater good.

I recently dug a small trench between the sidewalk and utility strip. During summer rains a great deal of the sidewalk water that would normally run into the street collected there and soaked into the soil slowly. In Los Angeles people often dig out the utility strip so that it is a bit lower than the sidewalk and serves as a large catch basin, some even plant gardens in them. I'm not sure NJ is ready for that, but my little trench did divert several gallons of water away from storm drains.

In a similar fashion I am adding a 'rain garden' to my front gardens. Essentially its a recessed garden into which rain water can collect from downspouts instead of rushing toward the street. Mine is set up in an English Cottage garden style and is thriving.

These simple solutions won't unpave paradise but they will reduce my impact on the environment and infrastructure. Check out @NJTrees on twitter for similar home solutions to runoff and environmental stewardship.  


Exactly, John (0.00 / 0)
Rain Gardens are an LID technique.  We tend to think raised garden beds are good - but they deflect water.  We should think opposite that - and lower our planting beds so that they save water. Unfortunately, in NJ, we have landscapers that put berms everywhere because they are too lazy to dig to put in a row of plants.  Even in parking lots the grass strips are raised - making us need to water the grass.  If we lower them, they will help store water before it seeps into the ground.  Here are some pictures of rain gardens http://www.google.com/search?q...  

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.

[ Parent ]
Other LID techniques: (0.00 / 0)
Rainbarrels, Bioretention strips, green roofs, pervious pavers on residential driveways, pervious asphalt and concrete for parking lots and streets, minimizing the width of pavement when we redo roads, etc.  Here is a cool demo of pervious pavement - it can be either pervious concrete or pervious asphalt. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...

Here is a How To put together by Rutgers if you want to do your own raingarden:  http://www.water.rutgers.edu/F...

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.


[ Parent ]
Even in an urban setting (4.00 / 1)
where we need to retrofit - there are solutions for tight spots.  http://www.filterra.com/  The key is to slow the water down by disconnecting the impervious area providing the runoff - sidewalk, road, from the municipal system.  This not only slows it down just enough to give the municipal system a chance to get rid of  water more easily, it has been determined that just 3 inches of mulch over the soil in these systems, removes most of the heavy metals and pollutants in the  runoff. You just put one of these in just upstream and next to any existing catch basin.

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.

[ Parent ]
Wayne Township (0.00 / 0)
wouldn't let me use these either.

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.

[ Parent ]
Rain Barrells (0.00 / 0)
Has anyone even mentioned rain barrels yet? I'm planning on adding them to my landscape once I find some I really like.

The LA Times has some really great water saving techniques in the gardening section that, although aimed at xerascapers, translate well to NJ where our greater concern is runoff.  


Guess which NJ town would not (0.00 / 0)
allow me to use pervious pavement and pervious sidewalks and just added a law preventing the use of pervious driveways? And also demanded I make the entire front yards lawn and add impervious sidewalk to BOTH sides of a tiny street that they wanted to be 30 ft wide pavement?  If you said Wayne - the flooding capital of NJ - who happens to be uphill neighbors to stricken Paterson - you would be correct.

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.

Carol (0.00 / 0)
Is this pervious pavement story something you might like to expand into a post for Sunday when Pres. Obama is in NJ?  

It's not a particularly snappy signature, but here's what I think we need in the next NJ Democratic State Chair.  

[ Parent ]
I'd like to. (0.00 / 0)
I am very concerned for those who need new construction done in Wayne after the flood, because nearly all the other engineers I know refuse to take on ANY work in Wayne right now. The Borough ordinances actually increase the amount of runoff to handle and the total volume flowing to the municipal system as well as increase the cost for the builders while making flooding worse.  Absolutely everything they demand is the exact opposite of what the NJDEP (and good stormwater management) tells stormwater engineers to do.   I have been designing stormwater management systems for 11 years now (none have failed, by the way) - and I have NEVER seen this level of insanity.  

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.

[ Parent ]
Willowbrook Mall (0.00 / 0)
I doubt that you were working with Wayne when the Mall was established.

But why weren't the owners demanding some protection when the Mall was established?  Flooding in Wayne was well known.  

You don't have to answer.  I know you are busy.


[ Parent ]
Actually, I don't work with Wayne (0.00 / 0)
I am in private practice and have designed commercial and residential stormwater systems all over North Jersey.

For many many years residents were asking for a stormwater solution in Wayne - around 1990 a $1.8 billion tunnel was proposed to empty all the way into Newark Bay, but fortunately - (or unfortunately - depending on your perspective), it never happened. That was before LID techniques were even developed. Most engineers these days are trying to get rid of dams and tunnels and getting people out of harm's way so that the river can naturally accommodate the extra flow.  Look what happened in New Orleans when where the Army Corps built levees.  The best most effective and less costly solution is the natural one.  http://www.hackensackriverkeep...

One Vote.  Yours.  It really does matter.


[ Parent ]
Get Your Ark Ready | 16 comments
Featured Stories

Hate Ads? Make them disappear.
Subscribe:

Blue Jersey Essentials

 EDITORIAL DIRECTOR
 Rosi Efthim

 STAFF WRITERS
 Adam L a/k/a/ clammyc
 Bill Orr
 Deciminyan
 Hopeful
 Jeff Gardner
 Jersey Jazzman
 KendalJames
 Senator Loretta Weinberg
 the_promised_land
 Rosi Efthim

» About | FAQ | In the News
» 
» Tips:
» Front Page RSS Feed
» User Diaries RSS Feed
» Blue Jersey on Twitter » Blue Jersey on Facebook » Blue Jersey T-shirts
ADVERTISEMENT

Blog Roll

» Alicia Menendez
» Alive and Kickin
» Baristanet
» Blog the Fifth
» Capitol Quickies
» The Center of NJ Life
» Channel Surfing
» Channel Surfing
» Deciminyan
» The Englewood Report
» Frank Lobiondo Record
» Fred Snowflack
» Freedom to Tinker
» Garden State Grapevine
» ClearysNoteBook
» Herb Jackson
» Hoboken Journal
» Hoboken Now
» Jersey Blogs
» Jersey Jazzman
» Middletown Mike
» More Monmouth Musings
» NJ Domestic Partnership
» NJ Politics Unusual
» NJ Voices: Policy Watch
» On Our Radar
» The Opinion Mill
» Other Spaces
» Plainfield Plaintalker
» PolitickerNJ
» Retire Garrett
» Ruins of Trenton
» Senator Ray Lesniak
» Stovetop Diplomacy
» Sustainable Cherry Hill
» The Subversive Garden
» Teaneck Progress
» Trenton Kat
» We Don't Need Permission
» Xpatriated Texan

Cartoons

» M.e. Cohen
» Jimmy Margulies
» Drew Sheneman
» Rob Tornoe
Search




Advanced Search












Ads do not constitute
an endorsement
from Blue Jersey.



Blue Jersey Gear

Visit the Blue Jersey store. T-shirts, bumper stickers & more!


Shirts available in dozens of styles and colors.



Visit the Blue Jersey Store

Contact Us
» Editor: 
» Press releases: 
» Advertising inquiries: 
» Tips:
About Us
» About Blue Jersey
» Blue Jersey in the News
» FAQ/Usage
» 
» RSS Feed

Misc Stuff
» Blue Jersey Radio
» Blue Jersey on Twitter
» Facebook Group
» MySpace Page
» NJ Politics 101 Wiki
» Blue Jersey Podcast
» Screaming Carrot Award
» Contribute to Blue Jersey
7966 satisfied users, visits and 0 subpoenas served since Sept 28, 2005
© Blue Jersey, powered by the mighty SoapBlox.
Powered by: SoapBlox