8 users logged onTips: BlueJerseyDotCom (AIM) |      

Log In
Sign Up | Forgot Password?

LD-8: Judge rules against Carl Lewis, who plans an appeal

by: Rosi Efthim

Thu Apr 28, 2011 at 05:11:58 PM EDT



Carl Lewis has lost his bid to have a judge reinstate his name on New Jersey primary election ballots this afternoon, as the judge upholds the state's 4-year residency rule. Via politickernj, U.S. District Court Judge Noel Hillman in his ruling:

Whatever a candidate's personal qualities may be, they have to have four years of boots on the ground.
[ snip ]
These powers and this state constitution has been part of the standing law of this state for 167 years. While difficult, the voters of the State of New Jersey have long had the power to change this provision and at least twice passed... The power to change it and the failure to change it... stands for the proposition that the majority of people want a four-year (residency requirement).
The decision, this afternoon in U.S. District Court in Camden, comes in just under the wire in the schedule for ballots to be sent by mail today. Yesterday, the judge granted a preliminary injunction to stop election officials from issuing those primary ballots before he rendered his decision.  
Rosi Efthim :: LD-8: Judge rules against Carl Lewis, who plans an appeal
GOP Senator Dawn Addiego has never gotten the kind of media attention that the 9-time Olympic gold medalist has gotten since rumors started he might jump in the race as a Democrat. And it's been a roller-coaster that probably hasn't come to a full stop yet. Lewis is appealing and a separate challenge was filed in state court. The ups and downs included the revelation that Chris Christie tried to talk him out of running almost right up to his announcement, then snatched away their plan to make Lewis physical fitness ambassador for New Jersey as punishment. An administrative law judge dismissed the GOP's case just days ago, saying they had not met the burden of proof. That kicked the decision to Kim Guadagno, who by Gov. Christie's appointment operates not only as his LG but as Secretary of State, which makes the GOP ticket's #2 behind the most political governor in NJ history the top election official in the state. Complicated, in a post-Katherine Harris world.

Republican comment since Lewis got in has been fairly insulting, the latest coming this morning as Dawn Addiego broke her silence to say she agrees with Guadagno's decision and suggested Lewis probably isn't qualified for the NJ Senate anyway, not knowing as much as she appears to suggest she knows about the people there.

Lewis argues that New Jersey's residency rules are obsolete, that the requirements are a holdover from a time before the internet made it possible for people to share information and research candidates quickly. But the Republicans who challenged his eligibility to run say those requirements are in place so voters can have ample time to familiarize themselves with candidates.  

Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Distractions and Deflections (0.00 / 0)
This is and has been a stupid move by the Norcross/Sweeney axis of DiNO'ism from the start.
It rates right up with McCain taking Sarah Palin as his running mate. This wasn't a decision about the PEOPLE of New jersey so much as it was of putting a recognized name in the box that people would vote for and who would have to be hand-held (controlled) by Sweeney and Norcross.

"Boss" Politics is just slimy and insulting to the people of New Jersey and the Democratic party.

Enough putting up with Sweeney and Norcross and their manipulating the people of New Jersey for their own ego's and bank accounts. These two are no better than the Rovian's under Bush and the new GOP fringe.

Neither is a REAL Democrat and neither qualifies as even a  moderate liberal.

If we don't stand together, we fall alone
That didn't last long.



Is it the source or the candidate? (3.00 / 1)
That is so troubling to you?

I can't pass that kind of judgment on Lewis. I just don't know enough yet about his plans, his ideas and his hopes and dreams. From what I've seen, I'm not put off.

That may sound like it goes toward the Republicans' argument, but that's not right. Across the country, these months are when candidates do so much outreach.  

It's not a particularly snappy signature, but here's what I think we need in the next NJ Democratic State Chair.  


[ Parent ]
Both (0.00 / 0)
Lewis has zero political/government experience and has been a "Trophy" placement in the Christie Press Machine.

Everything about the pick reeks of "Face" over "Function" and given the heated state of politics in New Jersey, Sweeney and Norcross should have seen this coming from a mile and a half off... Unless, of course, this is exactly what they want. A distraction to take focus of what Lewis brings or DOESN'T bring to the table.

In all we have heard, we have heard exactly nothing about Lewis' positions, his stand on labor, taxes, spending, privatization, Boss Politics.

Instead what we hear is how great this fight is for the democrats because making Lewis a "Victim" makes him more electable. That seems like putting the cart before the horse in that how is he electable if we know nothing about his positions?

Here is what we know about him, in a nutshell; He runs fast, he won gold medals, he was hand-picked by Christie to be a spokesperson, he calls Christie "Friend", he was hand-picked by Norcross and Sweeney, not the people of NJ who didn't even know he was LIVING in NJ before he was announced because he wasn't. He wasn't even voting in NJ. That is the extent of it.

Now, because he is being targeted by the ReTHUGS, he is "The Guy"? That is a weak and, honestly disrespectful argument to make for the people of New Jersey.

I am put off because the timing, lack of information, unnecessary fight and air or "Carpet-Bagging" are too much to ignore. something isn't on the up and up with how this has been played and it creates doubt and discomfort around Mr. Lewis in regards to exactly what you don't yet know about him.

There should be a choice for the Dems here and not just the chosen anointment, ignoring the lack of a back-story on ideology and idealism.

I personally have nothing against Mr. Lewis. I don't have anything against a lot of people but that doesn't mean I am going to blindly accept them and the fight they create because I am told to. This fight has distracted all from WHO Mr. Lewis is and turned it into a paper-thin validation of "Because the republicans don't want to run against him."

The weakness of the party is heavily based on people being put forward who aren't ready, skilled or ideologically intune enough and are just "Face-value electable". This just seems to perpetuate the that condition. How many people "Leading" in NJ are "Placements" by Norcross or other unelected "Bosses"?

I hope that clarifies my doubts and shows they are not without merit.

If we don't stand together, we fall alone
That didn't last long.



[ Parent ]
And It wasn't an attack on Lewis (0.00 / 0)
It was a dissection of the motivation of sweeney and Norcross in picking a non-resident with no political history aside from being tagged by Christie for some honorarium position related to being born in Jersey and a sports hero.

The same complaints of "what experience" & "just a name and face that'll get votes" were lodged by "Our team" about John Runyan not so long ago.

If we don't stand together, we fall alone
That didn't last long.



[ Parent ]
Sweeney hater (0.00 / 0)
I give you credit,no matter what happens you spin it as a Sweeney problem.

Taking Lewis was a good move. LD8 was a lost district. Lewis ,with name recognition can make this interesting.

The Republicans are fighting this so hard because they know that if Lewis stays in it will cost them a ton of money to beat him.

Only YOU do not see the brilliance of the Sweeney strategy.  


[ Parent ]
No Spin Necessary (0.00 / 0)
Sweeney and Norcross picked and anointed him.

This attitude that any body in the chair that ain't theirs is a disease that needs to be remedied with picking and or GROOMING people who can do more than just get elected.

All the Tea Baggers we see are the result of the same, insulting and patronizing attitude towards the voters. It's no wonder that Dems stayed home last election cycle. If they don't get the respect and deference they deserve, the DON'T SHOW.

Being a LIBERAL is about more than electing people who will put a (d) after their name. It is about advancing people who are READY and ABLE to make the office effective. Besides gold medals, a (d) after his moniker and Sweeney's blessing, what do you know about Lewis?

You call it being a HATER, I call it being a responsible liberal who wants more than a body in the seat that will do what Sweeney and Norcross tell him.her to do. Based on Sweeney's attitude towards Labor, HIS is the LEAST favorable influence Democrats in New Jersey need.

Loyalty is admirable, blind loyalty is ignorance.

If we don't stand together, we fall alone
That didn't last long.



[ Parent ]
You have a point (motivation of Sweeney, Norcross) (0.00 / 0)
But comparing them to Rove is too harsh. Obviously Lewis's run was motivated by the name recognition factor. One could call Hilllary Clinton a carpettbagger with no hands on gov. experience (other than by marriage) with serious name recognition when she ran for Senator from N.Y. and trounced Lazio even in Rep. upstate but that's absurd. Carl Lewis was filing and his capabilities remains to be seen. I personally would love to see another district go Dem.  

mmgth

[ Parent ]
I DID call her a Carpet Bagger... (0.00 / 0)
I have an ethical obligation to do more than just Rah Rah my team.
I have an obligation to demand a higher standard because being like them makes us THEM.

If we don't stand together, we fall alone
That didn't last long.



[ Parent ]
And Hillary Had A Lot of Experience (0.00 / 0)
Both as a spouse of and active participant in Bill Clinton's advisory circle. Is Carl the spouse of a twice elected governor and twice elected president with a degree in law and having graduated Cum Laud?

If we don't stand together, we fall alone
That didn't last long.



[ Parent ]
Stilll like to see a Dem. senator in the 8th (0.00 / 0)
 I did say the carpetbagger/no government experience issue re Hillary Clinton was absurd as she proved to be a quite capable U.S. senator but at the time of her nomination these capabilities were unproven. If she was not married to Bill Clinton would she have been nominated? If Patti Scialfa wasn't the amazing  Bruce Springsteen's girlfriend, later wife would she be playing guitar wth the E Street band? Hey, she sounds great by the way. Carl Lewis's capabilities are also yet unproven. Okay, the comparison doesn't work for you. Fair enough. I also take your point. I'm more of a cynic.  

mmgth

[ Parent ]
Patti Scialfa... (0.00 / 0)
...was a member of the E Street Band well before she ever became Springsteen's girlfriend/wife.  He was married to Julienne Richards while Scialfa was in the band.

[ Parent ]
Thanks (0.00 / 0)
Now I don't have to write something far snarkier in response to the unthinking and tone deaf post above yours.

[ Parent ]
Bring it on (0.00 / 0)
Love to here your snark on my unthinking tonedeafness. I was a fan when Bruce Springsteen and the E Street band were playing  the Main Point (many times). This was a folk scene but the place HAD to book them whenever possible.    

mmgth

[ Parent ]
Snark (0.00 / 0)
is not necessary.

The examples you chose (Clinton and Scialfa) imply that women have to be married to more famous men to obtain name recognition.   It's called "derived status."

We could argue for a long time about your theory, but it's not worth either of our efforts.

For me, reading your post was like hearing nails scratched across a chalkboard.

Bobby Kennedy had name recognition and a rather lousy record when he carpetbagged his way into the NYS senate.  He grew with the job.

Bob Menendez could have toiled in Hudson County forever until Corzine picked him as interim senator. He has a decent record, except for a few things.

And in running against Menendez, Tom Kean Jr.'s considerable name recognition didn't work out so well for him.

I don't know what it all means, but IMO your post was inartful at best.


[ Parent ]
More nail scatching on a blackboard (0.00 / 0)
Okay, I'll take inartfulness over unthinking tonedeafness. Rather you pick on RFK and Sen. Menendez anyway though ??? huh? But this has nothing to do with Carl Lewis. Never said women have to be married to famous men to gain name recognition by the way.  

mmgth

[ Parent ]
scratching n/t (0.00 / 0)


mmgth

[ Parent ]
OK (0.00 / 0)
I thought the discussion involved carpetbagging and name recognition.

I didn't care for your examples because they seemed flat out stereotypical.

You didn't like mine because you think I was picking on RFK and Menendez.

So lets call the whole thing off.  I, too, would like to know more about Carl Lewis' positions.


[ Parent ]
Off topic (0.00 / 0)
You're right about her Patti Scialfa) joining the E Street band before their relationship was known (backup vocals). But my point is that her relationship with The Boss was a factor in her being featured in the E Street. As for your first sentence...yeah, o...kay. She proved to be a great addition to the band. Now for Carl Lewis. I wouldn't dismiss his abilities out of hand. That's my point admittedly awkwardly expressed  

mmgth

[ Parent ]
To clarify (0.00 / 0)
Comment was a response to rachel's dad.

mmgth

[ Parent ]
I don't know... (0.00 / 0)
...how long you have been a fan, but if it goes back to the 80s when Scialfa joined the band, you would know that the only relationship that she had with Springsteen back then was professional.

She earned that spot by being a fixture in the NJ/NY music scene even longer than Springsteen himself, albeit without the commercial success.  Much later, she would find a place in his heart and his in hers as his marriage with Phillips proved itself to be as fraudulent as his fans thought it was when it was announced.

Obviously, the years that Springsteen and Scialfa spent on the road allowed a professional relationship to blossom into a personal one as well, but it would be wrong for anyone to think that the latter had any impact on the former.  The opposite is clearly the truth.


[ Parent ]
SO off topic and all my fault (0.00 / 0)
Fan since the early '70's. To respond to the rest... o... kaaay. Jeez sorry. You sound like an old fashioned romantic (in a good way). Now,I am sort of ashamed of getting off topic re Carl Lewis. My point is that name recognition is a valid asset. Still would like to see what he has to offer running in the 8th.  

mmgth

[ Parent ]
not an unreasonable decision (0.00 / 0)
Though it's rather poor taste to cite the replaced 1844 Constitution, which took away the right to vote for blacks and women.  


Frank LoBiondo Record and Jon Runyan Watch

Lets get Al Sharpton on this (0.00 / 0)
Is he still in vineland helping out   state Senator Jeff Van Drew ...at the labor  union rally  

Featured Stories

Hate Ads? Make them disappear.
Subscribe:

Blue Jersey Essentials

 EDITORIAL DIRECTOR
 Rosi Efthim

 STAFF WRITERS
 Adam L a/k/a/ clammyc
 Bill Orr
 Deciminyan
 Hopeful
 Jeff Gardner
 Jersey Jazzman
 KendalJames
 Senator Loretta Weinberg
 the_promised_land
 Rosi Efthim

» About | FAQ | In the News
» 
» Tips:
» Front Page RSS Feed
» User Diaries RSS Feed
» Blue Jersey on Twitter » Blue Jersey on Facebook » Blue Jersey T-shirts
ADVERTISEMENT

Blog Roll

» Alicia Menendez
» Alive and Kickin
» Baristanet
» Blog the Fifth
» Capitol Quickies
» The Center of NJ Life
» Channel Surfing
» Channel Surfing
» Deciminyan
» The Englewood Report
» Frank Lobiondo Record
» Fred Snowflack
» Freedom to Tinker
» Garden State Grapevine
» ClearysNoteBook
» Herb Jackson
» Hoboken Journal
» Hoboken Now
» Jersey Blogs
» Jersey Jazzman
» Middletown Mike
» More Monmouth Musings
» NJ Domestic Partnership
» NJ Politics Unusual
» NJ Voices: Policy Watch
» On Our Radar
» The Opinion Mill
» Other Spaces
» Plainfield Plaintalker
» PolitickerNJ
» Retire Garrett
» Ruins of Trenton
» Senator Ray Lesniak
» Stovetop Diplomacy
» Sustainable Cherry Hill
» The Subversive Garden
» Teaneck Progress
» Trenton Kat
» We Don't Need Permission
» Xpatriated Texan

Cartoons

» M.e. Cohen
» Jimmy Margulies
» Drew Sheneman
» Rob Tornoe
Search




Advanced Search












Ads do not constitute
an endorsement
from Blue Jersey.



Blue Jersey Gear

Visit the Blue Jersey store. T-shirts, bumper stickers & more!


Shirts available in dozens of styles and colors.



Visit the Blue Jersey Store

Contact Us
» Editor: 
» Press releases: 
» Advertising inquiries: 
» Tips:
About Us
» About Blue Jersey
» Blue Jersey in the News
» FAQ/Usage
» 
» RSS Feed

Misc Stuff
» Blue Jersey Radio
» Blue Jersey on Twitter
» Facebook Group
» MySpace Page
» NJ Politics 101 Wiki
» Blue Jersey Podcast
» Screaming Carrot Award
» Contribute to Blue Jersey
7965 satisfied users, visits and 0 subpoenas served since Sept 28, 2005
© Blue Jersey, powered by the mighty SoapBlox.
Powered by: SoapBlox