8 users logged onTips: BlueJerseyDotCom (AIM) |      
Log In
Sign Up | Forgot Password?

APP forgets they're supposed to objectively report the news

by: Jason Springer

Wed Sep 16, 2009 at 10:30:00 AM EDT



After reading the Asbury Park Press published coverage of Rep. John Adler's health care town hall, I can't decide which aspect of the piece is more annoying:

  • That they use anti-reform frames and don't bother saying so?
  • That they don't explain anything about Adler's position?
  • That they seem a little ... invested ... in continuing controversy?

    The coverage, to start with, abandons objective reporting when it presents health care reform as Obamacare without either identifying that term as one the anti-reform activists use or explaining what it means. It's the complete substitution of opinion for objectivity.

    APP goes on to set the tone for the article with this reminder of how things went last time apparently:

    The last time Rep. John Adler, D-N.J., visited the township to discuss health care reform, he was shoved by an irate constituent who got into the congressman's face over the issue.

    Does the article let us know whether the irate constituent was for reform, or against it? Or anything about that constituent's thoughts or feelings? No. Then why bring the incident up, unless you just want to suggest a brawl to keep people reading?

    And then there's this:

    Adler, a freshman congressman who occupies the 3rd District seat previously held for 25 years by Republican Jim Saxton, does not even support current health care reforms proposed by President Barack Obama and his own congressional leadership.

    But as a Democrat, Adler has been on the receiving end of the anger from some opposed to so-called "Obamacare," while getting criticism from some on the left who feel betrayed by the conservative positions he has taken since assuming office in January.

    What, really? Does the reporter grasp that there are different proposals, from both House and Senate? Which of them does Adler object to? And why? You'd have to read better reporting to know that Adler opposes not a bill of the President (a quick review of how a bill becomes law would be advised), but the House leadership bill, which is different from the Senate proposal. All of which doesn't get mentioned because the shoving from the last meeting was worth the column inches, and not that.

    So-called "Obamacare"? Maybe we should call this so-called objective reporting."  

  • Jason Springer :: APP forgets they're supposed to objectively report the news
    Tags: (All Tags)
    Print Friendly View Send As Email
    no surprise to hear this (0.00 / 0)
    I just logged on to app to see the conservative news of the day and I come across this great headline..."Senate's 10-year health fix could cost the U.S. a staggering $856 billion"...despite the objective reporting they did not and never seem to do that all of the health reform plans are deficit-neutral and paid for with increases on the wealthiest Americans and efficiencies in Medicare.  

    The app is a joke of a paper and for just once I would love to see some in-depth accurate reporting instead of the conservative drivel they so often print.


    I am sorry to say this... (4.00 / 1)
    ....but i think it was fair to attribute the "obamacare" meme to Adler himself.

    Unless my lying ears deceived me the only one who uttered that phrase at the Cherry Hill townhall was the Congressman himself.

    (SIGH)

  • Jay_Lass on Twitter.

  • Jay (0.00 / 0)
    That's extraordinary. Sickening.

    If anybody is in a position to capture Rep. John Adler using the term Obamacare I think we should take every opportunity to get that on video.

    For the next campaign.  

    It's not a particularly snappy signature, but here's what I think we need in the next NJ Democratic State Chair.  


    [ Parent ]
    OBAMACARE (0.00 / 0)
    Never mind, Jay.

    We've got it in his own words and in print. Headline, by John Adler:

    "Obamacare" bills miss mark on long-term affordability

    Asbury Park Press, of course. Classic.  

    It's not a particularly snappy signature, but here's what I think we need in the next NJ Democratic State Chair.  


    [ Parent ]
    What I want to know (0.00 / 0)
    from John Adler, or from Asbury Park Press:

    Who used the term Obamacare in the headling of this editorial by Rep. Adler?

    If APP stuck it on there, fine. Then they should acknowledge that, and the congressman should say whether the use of that term accurately reflects what he thinks.

    If the choice of that term was Rep. Adler's - as Jay Lassiter believes - I'd like to see him stand behind that term. This issue is critical, and knowing where our newest member of Congress stands is very important.

    It's not a particularly snappy signature, but here's what I think we need in the next NJ Democratic State Chair.  


    [ Parent ]
    Blame the APP (0.00 / 0)
    Here's the headline on the op-ed piece as it appears on Adler's homepage:

    "Health Care Reform Must Cut Costs"

    You can bet some copy editor who works on the APP's op-ed page wrote that headline (that's almost always how it works).

    Adler, tho, could be faulted for not objecting after it was published.


    [ Parent ]
    apologies ... (0.00 / 0)
    ... for the ambiguity in my last comment.

    My point is that the headline from Adler's press release is tame & does not contain the word "Obamacare."

    I think it's safe to blame the use of that word in the published headline on the APP.

    Generally, when you submit an op-ed to a newspaper, you have no control over the headline.


    [ Parent ]
    The byline ... (0.00 / 0)

    ... says it all.  I know people in the APP newsroom.  It's apparently long and widely known that Erik Larson is a rightwing nutbag who loves to spin "color" and is aptly rewarded for it by his managing editor, another rightwinger.  The two may also share inferior education, but I couldn't get specifics on that.

    Larson often is assigned select stories like this that aren't even near his beat.  I don't wonder why.  He always has reminded me of Jeff Gannon/James Guckert/"the top".

    As for the "Obamacare" on the op-ed, I called a mate.  That headline would be the responsibilty of Editorial Page Editor Andy (or Randy?) Bergmann.  And I was told it's not surprising, either.

    It's interesting how the comments on the article reflect its baiting, isn't it?



    ADVERTISEMENT
    Featured Stories
    The religion thing
    by: Rosi Efthim - Feb 01
    34 Comments

    Blue Jersey Radio

    The Voice of NJ Politics
    » Next show: Tues @ 8:00p
    » Hosts: Jeff Gardner & Jason Springer
    » Call in: (646) 652-2773
    » iTunes Subscribe | Archives


    Follow us on Twitter @bluejersey

    Hate Ads? Make them disappear.
    Subscribe:

    Blue Jersey Essentials

     EDITORIAL DIRECTOR
     Rosi Efthim

     TECHNICAL DIRECTOR
     Jason Springer

     STAFF WRITERS
     Adam L a/k/a/ clammyc
     bytheshore73
     Hopeful
     Jeff Gardner
     Scott Weingart
     Senator Loretta Weinberg
     Vincent Solomeno
     Jason Springer
     Rosi Efthim

    » About | FAQ | In the News
    » 
    » Tips:
    » Front Page RSS Feed
    » User Diaries RSS Feed
    » Blue Jersey on Twitter » Blue Jersey on Facebook » Blue Jersey T-shirts
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Blog Roll

    » Alicia Menendez
    » Alive and Kickin
    » Barista of Bloomfield Ave
    » Blog the Fifth
    » Capitol Quickies
    » The Center of NJ Life
    » Channel Surfing
    » Daily Newarker
    » The Englewood Report
    » Frank Lobiondo Record
    » Fred Snowflack
    » Freedom to Tinker
    » Fresh Jersey (Mike Kelly)
    » Garden State Grapevine
    » Gloucester City News
    » Green Jersey
    » Herb Jackson
    » Hoboken Journal
    » Hoboken Now
    » The Inside Clamdigger
    » Jersey Blogs
    » Lassiter Space
    » Latinos NJ
    » Middletown Mike
    » More Monmouth Musings
    » NJ Domestic Partnership
    » NJ Politics Unusual
    » NJ Voices: Policy Watch
    » On Our Radar
    » The Opinion Mill
    » Other Spaces
    » Plainfield Plaintalker
    » PolitickerNJ
    » Retire Garrett
    » Ruins of Trenton
    » Senator Ray Lesniak
    » Stovetop Diplomacy
    » Sustainable Cherry Hill
    » The Subversive Garden
    » Teaneck Progress
    » Trenton Kat
    » We Don't Need Permission
    » Xpatriated Texan

    Cartoons

    » M.e. Cohen
    » Jimmy Margulies
    » Drew Sheneman
    » Rob Tornoe
    Search




    Advanced Search















    Ads do not constitute
    an endorsement
    from Blue Jersey.



    Blue Jersey Gear

    Visit the Blue Jersey store. T-shirts, bumper stickers & more!


    Shirts available in dozens of styles and colors.

    Visit the Blue Jersey Store

    Contact Us
    » Editor: 
    » Press releases: 
    » Advertising inquiries: 
    » Tips:
    About Us
    » About Blue Jersey
    » Blue Jersey in the News
    » FAQ/Usage
    » 
    » RSS Feed

    Misc Stuff
    » Blue Jersey Radio
    » Blue Jersey on Twitter
    » Facebook Group
    » MySpace Page
    » NJ Politics 101 Wiki
    » Blue Jersey Podcast
    » Screaming Carrot Award
    » Contribute to Blue Jersey
    5392 satisfied users, visits and 0 subpoenas served since Sept 28, 2005
    © Blue Jersey, powered by the mighty SoapBlox.