Will a Republican Succeed Chris Christie in Drumthwacket?

Conventional wisdom says that a Democrat will win this year’s New Jersey gubernatorial election. After all, the current Republican governor has been a disaster. His economic policies have caused our state to lag the rest of the region in recovering from the Bush Recession. His on-again, off-again bromance with SCROTUS has tarnished his tough guy image. Bridgegate was the tip of the iceberg in an administration rife with cronyism.

But just like conventional wisdom prematurely put Hillary Clinton in the White House, don’t discount the possibility of a Republican succeeding a failed party comrade in New Jersey. Democrats, who are fond of eating their young and ignoring the wisdom of the masses, may be on another path to disaster.

The party establishment jumped the gun by anointing former Goldman Sachs millionaire Jon Corzine Phil Murphy a year and a half before the election. Make no mistake – Murphy would be a more progressive governor than any of the top-seeded GOP contenders. But whether it’s fair or not, the Corzine albatross hangs around his neck – not something that will get progressive Democrats or independent voters to the polls in an off-year election.

Republicans, of course, have their own issues. Lieutenant Governor Kim Guadagno has spent the last six months distancing herself from Christie. Of course, she has her own scandals to explain away but she’s spent the last eight years courting donors and voters in her role as Secretary of State and Christie stand-in. Assemblyman Jack Ciattarelli is also running. He’s good in front of a television camera and has also started to distance himself from a generally pro-Christie voting record.

Then there’s the wildcard. Saturday Night Live’s Joe Piscopo is vying to follow in the footsteps of Al Franken, another SNL alum, by entering the political fray. Piscopo has indicated that he is considering running as an independent, which could make things easier for the GOP nominee.

A bit of math is in order: Suppose Piscopo manages to skim off 20 percent of the votes, based on his name recognition and people who are fed up with the major parties. And assume the voter turnout is 25 percent – a tad better than the turnout four years ago. Then the other 80 percent of the people who go to the polls represent only 20 percent of the registered voters. Hence, it would only take a bit more than 10 percent of registered voters to select our next governor. This makes voter turnout the most important issue, and voter turnout is correlated with two things: money (which both parties will have) and enthusiasm – something that Murphy so far has not evoked among many Democrats and Independents.

Our next governor will become a big factor in the 2020 legislative and congressional redistricting activities. So he or she will not just set the course for the next four years, but for the next decade. It would be a good idea if people could channel at least some of their anti-Trump energy into ensuring that New Jersey’s next governor is one that our people could be proud of.

Comments (2)

  1. Bertin Lefkovic

    The most likely scenario for a Republican win in November is Guadagno winning the Republican nomination in June, Christie exiting in July for a job at WFAN after his last budget has been completed, and Guadagno running in the fall as the incumbent.

    There won’t be much of an opportunity for her to govern during this time, but there would still be opportunities for her to do things, particularly things that would put her at odds with Christie and Trump, that could help her win. I don’t expect that this will happen, but it could.

  2. ken bank

    Joe Piscopo is a Trumpeteer. He may attract a few independent conservatives who otherwise would vote for Guadagno, but I can’t imagine any Democrat voting for him any more than I could imagine them voting for Jim Gearhart or Bill Spadea.

    Another point is that Murphy is running against a very unpopular incumbent administration that Guadagno was very much a part of. Trump won because he ran as much against Obama as he did Hillary. I’m sure Murphy will campaign the same way against Christie/Guadagno. As far as enthusiasm, after 8 years of Christie I think most Democrats and many independents will walk on broken glass to get to the polls and vote for any Democrat whether they worked for Goldman Sachs or Burger King. As far as Republicans hanging the Goldman Sachs label on Murphy, let them try. That would be like the time Christie criticized the commander of the National Guard for being overweight. I think the GOP would rather go after the Wiz, a career politician whose law firm has been fired for pay-to-play violation, and whose political past likely contains many closets full of all kinds of skeletons.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *