Can the Pinelands Survive the Christie/Trump Destruction?

Unless the courts intervene, today will be marked down in history as the beginning of the destruction of the New Jersey Pinelands. This morning, in the Grand Ballroom of a Cherry Hill hotel, hundreds of protesters (along with a handful of pro-pipeline advocates) witnessed that historical moment as the Pinelands Commission voted to approve a high-pressure natural gas pipeline through the pinelands.

This project violates the Pinelands Comprehensive Management Plan in that it provides only risk, with no benefit, to the people and environment within the reserve. It sets a dangerous precedent for other pipelines like Penn East.

As former Chairman Mark Lohbauer describes in this video, this approval is the beginning of a slide toward the bottom for this unique and irreplaceable asset belonging to the citizens of New Jersey.

The meeting was held in a large ballroom after hundreds of people were locked out of the previous hearing due to the size of the hall in which it was held. That was on a day of cold, inclement weather, and rather than wait outside, many people went home without being able to exercise their right to testify. Today’s crowd was raucous, but courteous. It did, however, drown out the actual vote of the Christie-stacked panel (which was 9-5-1, see comments for votes), and protests continued after the voting led by environmental advocates like Patty Cronheim as depicted in the second part of the video.

After the meeting, the New Jersey Sierra Club issued this statement:

“In an act of betrayal of the people of New Jersey, the Pinelands Commission broke their own rules and rubberstamped the South Jersey Gas Pipeline. This decision is a major blow to the Pinelands but the battle isn’t over yet. We will continue to fight against this dangerous and damaging pipeline coming through the Pinelands. We will go back to court if we have to in order to keep this unnecessary project from cutting a scar through our state and threatening our drinking water. We fought to save the Pinelands 40 years ago and we’re going to keep fighting now!”

Comments (2)

  1. deciminyan (Post author)

    Assemblyman Wisniewski Responds:

    Here is a statement from Assemblyman John Wisniewski issued shortly after the vote:

    Wisniewski Stands With Opponents Of Pinelands Pipeline

    SAYREVILLE, N.J. – Assemblyman John Wisniewski released the following statement in response to the Pinelands Pipeline being approved this morning:

    “The community’s strong objection — coupled with the fact it cuts through the pristine and undeveloped Pinelands — should have been enough to block this pipeline from going forward. Additionally, Gov. Chris Christie’s interference and bullying of the Pinelands commission further put the interests of the pipeline proponents over the concerns of local residents.

    “The controversy around this pipeline illustrates the need for New Jersey to re-prioritize how we solve our energy needs. We face a climate emergency and our next governor must move away from fossil fuels towards a more sustainable energy economy that focuses on wind and solar power.”

  2. deciminyan (Post author)

    How did your Commissioner vote? Here’s the vote from the Pinelands Preservation Alliance site:

    YES Sean Earlen, Burlington County appointee
    YES Paul E. Galletta, Atlantic County appointee
    NO Candace McKee Ashmun, Governor appointee
    YES Alan Avery, Ocean County appointee
    YES Bob Barr, Governor appointee
    YES William Brown, Cape May County appointee
    YES Joe Chila, Gloucester County appointee
    ABSTAINED Frank Hays, U.S. Secretary of the Interior appointee
    YES Jane Jannarone, Cumberland County appointee
    NO Edward Lloyd, Governor appointee
    NO Mark Lohbaur, Governor appointee
    YES Edward McGlinchey, Camden County appointee
    YES Gary Quinn, Governor appointee
    NO D’Arcy Rohan Green, Governor appointee

    And here are some sound bites from the attendees (45 seconds)


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *