Love Fest II

Last week, the Assembly Education Committee passed a tenure reform bill with all stakeholders lavishing praise on the legislators and on one another for coming up with a bill that was acceptable to all. Not to be outdone, today the Senate Budget and Appropriations Committee heard from many of the same folks, and the love fest continued. Senator Teresa Ruiz, the author of the Senate version, was the target of most of the adoration.

As Republican Senator Kevin O’Toole noted, “To see John Tomicki [of the League of American Families] and the NJEA [simultaneously] praise this effort…speaks volumes.”

While the GOP abstained as a bloc in the Assembly, today’s vote was unanimous for the Senate bill (which Governor Christie said he will support). No one went away completely happy. The NJEA objected to the fact that taxpayer-funded charter schools are not subject to these reforms. The New Jersey Press Association testified that the process for tenure hearings will not be transparent. Some praised the fact that this was a first step in the goal of complete elimination of tenure.

Here’s the complete testimony. Let us know what you think. Is this kumbaya or is it a sell-out?

Comments (2)

  1. Momotombo

    For posting the testimony today.  I could not be there but wanted to see it to answer for myself the exact question that you asked.  Honestly all that comes to mind is that I just bit into a candy that is too sweet and it does not sit well in me at all.

    They all ate from the same candy though, and ignored the elephant in the room — the actual teacher evaluation system to be used as the basis for the whole bill….and the student test scores that will be part of that…..

    Why is it that Assemblyman Diegnan could put forth a bill and get it through the Education committee without requiring the love fest demonstrated here?  What am I missing?  

  2. Jersey Jazzman

    1) They realize they can’t get what they really want, so they are jumping on here and claiming a victory just so they can say they won.

    2) They are gearing up for round 2.

    3) We are missing something.

    And, of course, all of the above.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *