The timing of my calling bull$h!t on Sen. Kean is just “happenstance”

As Hopeful notes below, a new poll by FDU shows (1) a dead heat between Senator Menendez and Tom Kean, Jr. for a race that is over two years from now, and (2) a very mixed bag on what people in NJ think about health care reform.  

As Hopeful notes, 42% of New Jerseyans think that they personally will be worse off if the current health care reform bill passes, while 37% feel that they personally will be better off if the current health care reform bill passes.  However, that 5% spread is reversed when the question is asked about the country as a whole, with a 45% – 40% margin indicating that the current health care bill will be better for the country.  Adding to this, there is a 5% margin (40% against, 35% for, 25% don’t know) when it comes to whether respondents would urge THEIR member of Congress to vote for or against ANY health care bill.

In response to all of this, Kean finds the one way to interpret these numbers that is made up of fairy dust:

“Our United States Senators should finally listen to the majority of New Jerseyans  and support a fresh approach to reforming our health insurance industry.”

What’s more, Kean said that the suspicious timing of his pontificating was merely “happenstance”.

Now, say what you want about the current health care bill – there certainly is more than enough things to like and dislike about the bill on an individual level, but the one thing that can NOT be said is what Kean is asserting about “a fresh approach”.  It is either (1) is this bill good for me, (2) is this bill good for the rest of the country or (3) do you want your Congressman to vote for ANY bill.  If Kean wants to be taken seriously, then he should actually say things that are accurate – especially when it comes to issues that he claims to represent “the majority of New Jerseyans” on and issues where he hopes to represent all of New Jerseyans.

When reached for comment, Adam L a/k/a clammyc noted that the timing of this post was merely “happenstance”.

Comments (2)

  1. Bill Orr

    Kean’s concern is not logic but the party line. And why does the party have this “line?”

    It is interesting how Rep. John Boehner, Sen. Mitch McConell and the whole cabal of Republicans and now even State Sen. Tom Kean are so virulently opposed to the health care reform legislation and so hell-bent on derailing it.  If it’s such a terrible idea, why, instead of attacking it so much, don’t they just vote against it and then take credit for being on the right side. Perhaps, they are afraid that it will not be such a disaster, and they will have to take blame for not having supported it, and worse suffer at the polls in november as a result. Being the party of “no” requires the Republicans to prevent a bill from being voted on when the results of the vote might later boomerang against them.

  2. Hopeful

    It may have a superficial attraction to people who didn’t pay attention but have concerns, but it’s not going to fly with Democrats who after all are the majority in Congress. Obama is right, get it over with, and move on to more popular subjects. Democrats believe this bill will hurt just about no one and help many, so it’s going to be a success in the long run.    


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *