The Crucible

Last night’s Health Care Town Hall with Frank Pallone in Red Bank was at once a magnificent exercise in democracy, and an unsettling display of ignorance and free-floating right-wing resentments – abortion, “illegals,” guns – spilling out of people willing to treat politics as sport, and shout down all comers.

A few people came with intelligently-expressed questions, support, or objections. But last night was owned by the loons. It all spun down to rabble early, and it almost never let up.

In 1953, Arthur Miller wrote a play about the 1692 Salem, Massachusetts witch trials, his allegorical commentary on his own time, when HUAC and Senator Joe McCarthy manufactured enemies of ordinary Americans. Sitting there last night, surrounded, I was reminded of The Crucible.

In it, Abigail Williams is the teenager who whips the girls around her into a frenzy, shouting out wild accusations, utterly taken by the passion of the moment, and completely manipulated by a girl acting in her own self-interest, and willing to ruin peoples’ lives. When another girl, Mary, is about to prove her a fraud, she whips her friends into a delirious panic, screaming they’re freezing, that Mary has bewitched them. In moments, Abilgail’s cries are the girls’ cries, and they are all screaming the same word. It’s a neat trick.

Last night’s Abigail Williams was a man in a light blue tee shirt bearing the date the next Congress is seated. His were the words that rifled around the room, in seconds. And it was all stupid.

To a woman fearful of losing her house to medical bills: Good! Lose your house! Lose your house! House! House! Houuuuuuuse!

When Margaret Mead was mentioned: What part of the jungle did you come from? Kumbaya! Kumbaya! Kumbayaaaaaaa!

When a mother tried to say how her disabled daughter and mentally disabled husband were dropped by their insurance: His fault! He couldn’t fill out the form because he’s an idiot! idiot! idiot!

Many times, the room just erupted in disconnected, incoherent drivel:

I wish your mother believed in abortion, Frankie!

Drill, baby, drill!


And this: Is Ted Kennedy dead yet?

Real objections – and support, and questions – about the public option were drowned out by a mob certain they’d been denied power, and determined to flex it hard.  So sure their rights to “the First Amendment” were being taken, that they made certain no one else could be heard. It was crazy. And it did not need to be.

Comments (8)

  1. frailamerica

    I got there a little before 7, and there was no way I was going to wait in that monster of a line, so I just walked around and took pictures of people and their signs.  As far those with signs, the anti-reformers definitely outnumbered the the pro-reformers, but everyone seemed pleasant enough.  I guess they were saving all the crazy for the meeting.  Plus, I assume the super-crazies got there the earliest, for the first meeting.

    But I’m glad I didn’t get in, because if I heard someone say that to the woman with the disabled family members, I probably would beat the shit out of them.  Not productive, to be sure, but it sounds like it wasn’t productive anyway.

  2. Rosi Efthim (Post author)

    Rush Holt has a Town Hall tonight 7pm: Middletown Arts Center, 36 Church St., Middletown 07748.

    John Adler’s is today, 4pm: Energy Expo, Burlington County Inst. of Technology, Westampton Campus, 695 Woodlane Road, Westampton, 08060. Maybe you can change his mind.

  3. EJZip

    Congressman Pallone never once lost his cool here in Red Bank Tuesday night. I can’t say that for former GOP Councilwoman Grace Cangemi who was seen barking Teabagger-babble at the top of her lungs from the Middle School balcony while the veins in her neck and temple throbbed with a sort of maniacal ferocity. She (and John Curley) brought with her a mob of ill informed, equally loud, friends from outside the sixth district. One of the first people to rush to the microphone was asked what town she lived in to which she replied “Tren-in” — clearly not in the 6th! Another was from Brooklyn and others from Rumson, Colts Neck and Fair Haven. So much for Pallone’s 6th District constituents being in the room for a meaningful discussion.

    Some of the people I encountered in line outside the school were from Pennsylvania, which isn’t anywhere close to the 6th Congressional District in NJ. The were angry eyed like village characters in Frankenstein but wearing red, white and blue!

    Thank you Congressman for your attempt to hold an open discussion on a topic you have worked diligently and intelligently on.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *